© 2021 Times Internet Limited. The Bhagavad Gita reveals the truth of real spirituality in just 700 verses. . If there is even a touch of material ego, there is no question of bhakti — it will be karma.Bhakti is the best devotion: one should be free from non-devotional desires of any kind. Hinduism - Hinduism - Karma, samsara, and moksha: Hindus generally accept the doctrine of transmigration and rebirth and the complementary belief in karma. The following conversation between His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada and some of his disciples took place in June 1974 during an early-morning walk in Geneva. Bhakti and Karma Yoga is the 8th book in the AYP Enlightenment series and a definite read for those who seek self-realization. Home | About Us | Contact Us | Subscriber Services | Policy | FAQ. In Karma or the path of Action the seeker should surrender all the fruits at the feet of the Lord and carry on the duties with total devotion in His name and as His instrument. Bhagavad Gita Essentials The Lord Guides us Home. I don't want followers. Krishna told him, bhakto ’si me . Jnana works with the mind, restructuring the mind so that conditioned thoughts, attitudes, and ways of responding are let go. The benefits of Bhakti Yoga are immense, as Swami Sivananda writes, “Bhakti softens the heart and removes jealousy, hatred, lust, anger, egoism, pride, and arrogance. However, there is no linearity always involved and any of these paths can come naturally to any person at any point in point. For example, Arjuna fought in the Battle of Kurukshetra, but because he fought for Krishna he is accepted as a great devotee. In bhakti we also work, but for Krishna's sake. Karma Yoga is a means for Jñāna Yoga and for Bhakti Yoga but also an end as it can lead to self-realization. But the rascals jump immediately to the Tenth Canto, to Krishna's dealings with the gopis. That is also Krishna consciousness, but it is not favorable and therefore it is not bhakti. Bhakti is the ultimate destination of the spiritual platform. Srila Prabhupada: Yes, but we are opening schools that teach Krishna consciousness, while your schools are teaching illusion. The yogi needs to understand that they are complementary. In this video, I briefly talk about three important types of yoga: bhakti yoga, Jinana Yoga, and Karma Yoga. Vinirmuktam means there should not be even a scent of material ego. (iv) Jnana yoga-The realization of the divinity through knowledge. Bhakti in true sense means attachment to god. Sense gratification is there in either case, but when you work for your personal sense gratification it is karma, and when you work for Krishna's sense gratification it is bhakti. These three yogas of action, knowledge and devotion are not seen as separate paths, but as different facets of the journey. Head, heart and hands. (iii) Raja yoga-The realization of the divinity through the control of the mind. Bhakti in true sense means attachment to god. Therefore Bhakti is an integral part of Karma Yoga. When we take the merits of our actions for our own self, it is called karma — it is not bhakti.The results of all our actions should go to the Supreme Lord, not to our own pocket. In āropa-siddhā there is no bhakti activity except the offering of results. If there is no form in the cause, then there can be no form in the effect either. Sometimes he's taking the body of a dog and desiring one "good result," and sometimes he's taking the body of a demigod and desiring another "good result." At the heart of bhakti is surrender, says Uttal, who lives in California but travels the globe leading kirtans and … Bhakti and karma look similar, but the quality is different. Bhakti Yoga by Swami Vivekananda is an introduction to Bhakti Yoga. Not for his own sense gratification, but for Krishna's sense gratification. From the foreword: “Bhakti Yogais a real, genuine search after the Lord, a search beginning, continuing, and ending in Love.One single moment of the madness of extreme love to God brings us eternal freedom. They wanted Him as their lover, and they went out from their homes in the middle of the night to dance with Him. So it appears that they acted sinfully—but they did not, because the center was Krishna. He fought, that's all. Bhakti Yoga can be practiced by itself or be integrated into other types of yoga or spiritual practices. Bhakti Yoga (Union through Devotion and Love) Bhakti Yoga is the Yoga of selfless love, compassion, humility, purity and the desire and serious intention to merge with God. "I want to serve Krishna." I've never found any other books by anyone else who lays out a more clear, effective and easy to follow path to self realization or enlightenment than Yogani. You perform agnihotra because you are a dvija, and you also engage in bhakti. Bhakti is one of the main spiritual paths in Hinduism, the others being Jnana (path of knowledge) and Karma (the path of action). Srila Prabhupada: He means that we should desire only to serve Him. God has infinite form. Swami Vivekananda an outstanding example of Karma Yoga was a great devotee of the Divine Mother Kali. Therefore Chaitanya Mahaprabhu recommends, ramya kacid upasana vraja-vadhu-vargena ya kalpita: "There is no better mode of worshiping Krishna than that practiced by the gopis. In simple terms, If a person does good things in his life, we can say he has done good Karma and if a person does wrongful acts in his life, we can say that he has done bad karma. (i) Karma yoga-the manner in which a man realizes his own divinity through works and duty. The Bhagavad Gita provides spiritual seekers with a map to the source of divinity Itself. In this way they become sahajiyas [pseudo devotees]. krishna-bhakti haya abhidheya-pradhana bhakti-mukha-niriksaka karma-yoga-jnana “Devotional service to Krishna is the chief function of the living entity. Karma and Jnana forms a transit route to the ultimate spiritual platform, provided, the J… In simple terms, If a person does good things in his life, we can say he has done good Karma and if a person does wrongful acts in his life, we can say that he has done bad karma. The more said about Bhakti, the lesser it is. Then he gives a description of Krishna's behavior with the gopis. Karma and Jnana forms a transit route … A person uses the body to do all physical activity with no outcome desire to reach the ultimate goal of yoga will be Karma yoga. "Bhakti and Karma Yoga" is the eighth book in the series, preceded by "Self-Inquiry," "Diet, Shatkarmas and Amaroli," "Samyama," "Asanas, Mudras and Bandhas," "Tantra," "Spinal Breathing Pranayama," and "Deep Meditation." I don't want beautiful women." ; A person having an emotion of love & compassion towards everything has the path of Bhakti yoga to reach the ultimate goal of yoga. Bhakti looks like karma, but it's not karma. Bhakti Yoga is the yoga of devotion; and Karma Yoga is the yoga of action. Bhakti Yoga: All people will experience emotions such as love, compassion, and devotion at points along the journey, regardless of which of the four paths of Yoga is predominant. Slept in … Living bhakti is our path of consciously loving God, not just on the surface, but deeply within our hearts in every moment of our lives.. Paramahamsa Vishwananda teaches that realising God is the ultimate purpose of having a human existence. Every path to the supreme contains these elements- be it a Karma Yoga, or a Jnana Marga or a Bhakti. Because if we can get complete reality, we can get everything. Bhramatam upary adhah: he's wandering up and down the universe, just like . Then what does He want? Why Bhakti is better than Jnana, karma and Yoga Marg - Hi friends I found this commentary on Bhaktiyoga and other yogas and found it useful for it cleared the doubts in … That is the secret. The whole process of rebirth, called samsara, is cyclic, with no clear beginning or end, and encompasses lives of perpetual, serial attachments. Jnana cannot be gained without love and action; bahkti cannot be understood without action and knowledge and karma cannot be perfect without love and knowledge. Karma Yoga and Bhakti Yoga: Bhikshu: Amazon.nl Selecteer uw cookievoorkeuren We gebruiken cookies en vergelijkbare tools om uw winkelervaring te verbeteren, onze services aan te bieden, te begrijpen hoe klanten onze services gebruiken zodat we verbeteringen … Why should we try to attain Krishna? This is going on. By Swami Vivekananda, Karma-Yoga and Bhakti-Yoga describes the way to reach perfection through the performance of daily work in a non-attached spirit (i.e. Jnana, Bhakti and Karma - Nithin SridharKarma, Bhakti and Jnana are the three main elements that are necessary for spiritual evolution. But he fought for Krishna. That is the difference. It is nothing else than to follow the 'First Commandment': "to love God with all your heart, mind and soul." Bhakti is a mutual bond between the Lord and His devotees. The problem is that the rascals cannot understand the difference between bhakti [devotional service] and karma [material activity]. There are different methods for the liberation of the conditioned soul – karma, jnana, yoga and bhakti – but all are dependent on bhakti.” Nithin Sridhar Karma, Bhakti and Jnana are the three main elements that are necessary for spiritual evolution. A Path to God 'Bhakti' means love and devotion to the Divine. In other words, you mix the two. Srila Prabhupada: Yes. . Bhakti Yoga is in constant progression through Manomaya Kosha, until Seeker is consumed and his/her separate, individual existence is no more. Karma-Yoga and Bhakti-Yoga, along with Jnna-Yoga and Rja-Yoga, are considered classics and outstanding treatises on Hindu philosophy. It can […] Kamsa also associated with Krishna—but as an enemy. guru-krishna-prasade paya bhakti-lata-bija, "After wandering up and down the universe for many lifetimes, one who is very fortunate comes to devotional life by the mercy of the spiritual master and Krishna." 817 quotes have been tagged as karma. Disciple: Will such persons experience a change of heart, since they're somehow or other associating with Krishna? All modes or expressions of yoga can be classified under these three disciplines. Bhakti-yoga wordt over het algemeen beschouwd als het oudste van de vier hoofd-paden naar spirituele bevrijding , waarvan de andere drie jñāna-yoga, karma-yoga en raja-yoga zijn. They get impersonal liberation, but they are not allowed to enter into the pastimes of Krishna in the spiritual world. Karma-Yoga - the path of selfless action) and by sublimating human affection into divine love (i.e. Karma marga is one of three paths to liberation (moksha) in Hinduism, according to the Bhagavad Gita.Also called karma yoga, it is the path of action without selfish motives. Bhakti-Yoga - the path of divine love).Karma-Yoga and Bhakti-Yoga, along with Jnna-Yoga and Rja-Yoga, are considered c Another example is the behavior of the gopis [Krishna's cowherd girlfriends]. Because if we can get complete reality, we can get everything. Bhakti looks like karma, but it's not karma. . It infuses joy, divine ecstasy, bliss, peace, and knowledge. Today he is struggling very hard for one "good result," but tomorrow he'll desire something else, because he must undergo a change of body when he dies. Someone following this path lives in harmony with his/her ethical duty, or dharma, and may tend to be socially active. It can […] I took 2 yoga classes today. That is not bhakti. The following persons are known as outstanding examples of Bhakti Yogis: As they spoke each one boasted about the sole importance of his path to liberation – and denounced the others for wasting their time. You are opening schools, and we are also opening schools.". Karma Yoga: Nobody can live in a body and the world without doing actions. It inspires me to let go of all the worrys i might have and just focus on myself happiness. Bhakti in true sense means attachment to god. The more said about Bhakti, the lesser it is. Disciple: So sense gratification is there even in devotional service? Karma means action, work or deed. Though it may take a lot of time, years to remove #Vasanas and #Surrender in Devotion and then one may burn for … Bhakti arose in South India in the 7th to 10th centuries in poems that the Alvars and the Nayanars composed in Tamil to the gods Vishnu and Shiva, respectively.Drawing on earlier Tamil secular traditions of erotic poetry as well as royal traditions, bhakti poets applied to the god what would usually be said of an absent lover or of a king. . Krishna says that He enters into a personal relationship with His bhakta who worships Him … In bhakti we also work, but for Krishna's sake. But Krishna wanted him to fight, so at last he surrendered and did it as a service for Krishna. ", But the rascals think, "Oh, this is very good. At first he was thinking, "Why shall I kill my kinsmen? Another example is the behavior of the gopis [Krishna's cowherd girlfriends]. Self-Realization), but one can attain Jnana through multiple paths… Srila Prabhupada: Yes. “Bhakti is the yoga of a personal relationship with God,” says musician Jai Uttal, who learned the art of devotion from his guru, the late Neem Karoli Baba. Conclusion. One should not imitate Krishna or try to kill Him. Still, the enemies of Krishna get salvation, because they have somehow or other thought of Krishna. what is that? Krishna has no material form; his form is transcendental. Every path to the supreme contains these elements- … Bhakti is the ultimate destination of the spiritual platform. Karma means action, work or deed. No. Krishna danced in the middle of the night with other men's wives, so let us also gather some girls and dance, and we will also enjoy like Krishna.". Let me leave the battlefield and go to the forest and become a mendicant." That is the difference. Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu said, na dhanam na janam na sundarim kavitam va jagad-isha kamaye: "I don't want wealth. Each one followed a different approach – one Raja yogi, one Jnana yogi, one Bhakti yogi and one Karma yogi! Bhakti must be anukulyena krishnanushilanam: favorable devotional service. (ii) Bhakti yoga-The realization of the divinity through devotion to, and love of a personal God. Copyright © 2002-2021 The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust International, Inc. All rights reserved. Why is it useful to understand Yoga according to these three aspects? By getting whom, we get all; by knowing whom, we know all — that is Krishna. In simple terms, If a person does good things in his life, we can say he has done good Karma and if a person does wrongful acts in his life, we can say that he has done bad karma. brahmanda bhramite kona bhagyavan jiva Srila Prabhupada: No. He did not change his fighting capacity as a warrior, but he changed his mentality. Bhakti and Karma Yoga - The Science of Devotion and Liberation Through Action: Yogani: Amazon.nl Selecteer uw cookievoorkeuren We gebruiken cookies en vergelijkbare tools om uw winkelervaring te verbeteren, onze services aan te bieden, te begrijpen hoe klanten onze services gebruiken zodat we verbeteringen kunnen aanbrengen, en om advertenties weer te geven. Swami Vivekananda's deep spiritual insight, fervid eloquence, and broad human sympathy shine forth in these works and offer inspiration to all spiritual seekers. What did Arjuna do? It is not that He says, "I don't want this, I don't want that. Karma hinduism translate this text to. Bhakti works with the heart, opening the heart, and the feelings of the divine experience. The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust International, Inc. That benediction is reserved for those who practice pure loving devotion to Krishna. It can be expressed […] priyo ’si me: "Arjuna, you are My dear devotee." . Krishna was a beautiful boy and the gopis were attracted to Him. To prevent this misunderstanding, Srila Vyasadeva has devoted nine cantos of the Bhagavatam to describing Krishna's position as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Disciple: What does Krishna mean when He says in the Bhagavad-gita that we should be desireless? Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. We will not want anything else.All our desires will be fulfilled and our problems solved. This is a gross misunderstanding of Krishna's pastimes with the gopis. For example, Arjuna fought in the Battle of Kurukshetra, but because he fought for Krishna he is accepted as a great devotee. Karma and Bhakti - Why should we try to attain Krishna? The other paths are Jnana marga (path of knowledge), Karma marga (path of works), Rāja … Moksha or Liberation is attained only through Atma-Jnana/Brahma-Jnana (i.e. That is the difference between a nondevotee and a devotee. Srila Prabhupada: Then he is a fool, because he does not know what "good results" really are. Bhakti and Karma If a person comes to Krishna bakthi and stops adding bad karma, will he be punished for past karma ... Hare Krishna. Karma-miśra-bhakti is when you perform bhakti activities along with karma, or prescribed duties, while desiring the result of the karma. By karma-misra-bhakti (bhakti mixed with fruitive inclination) one is elevated to the celestial kingdom, by jnana-misra-bhakti (bhakti mixed with mental speculation) one is able to merge in the Brahman effulgence, and by yoga-misra-bhakti (bhakti mixed with the desire for mystic perfections) one is able to realize the omnipotency of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. All rights reserved, Final Exams/Term End Exams Eradication Required - Learning Needs To Be Integrated than Outcome Based, The Pangolin And Other Vulnerable Species. Someone may work throughout day and night and an observer might say, ‘This person is a very good servitor.’ But if he is doing this work to satisfy his own material ego, then it is not bhakti.We should be free from all kinds of material identification. We can never find happiness independent of Him. Bhakti and karma look similar, but the quality is different. Krishna was a beautiful boy and the gopis were attracted to Him. ; For a person who wishes to reach the ultimate goal of yoga with mind’s intelligence, there is Gyana yoga. Let Me become zero." It contains everything you need to know about how to attain Self-knowledge and God-knowledge through bhakti, the path of devotion.. Sometimes he is rising to an elevated position, and then again he must come down and take the body of a dog or hog. This weekend has been so sweet to me. A karmi works for his own sense gratification, and a bhakta works for Krishna's sense gratification. Disciple: The nondevotee also says he knows what he wants, but he says, "I can accomplish the same good results without Krishna.". As the path of love and devotion, Bhakti does not focus on one specific deity, but the individual's personal god and oneness with this supreme being and the universe. The term Bhakti refers to one of several alternate spiritual paths to moksha (spiritual freedom, liberation, salvation) in Hinduism, and it is referred to as bhakti marga or bhakti yoga. And karma works with being in the world and relating to other people, relating to … We usually associate Karma, Jnana and Bhakti Yoga with Lord Krishna’s teachings to Arjuna on the battlefield in the Bhagavad Gita. You are distributing food, and we are also distributing food. [Chaitanya-charitamrita, Madhya 19.151], Disciple: Well, the nondevotee will say, "We are also doing good service. Karma means action, work or deed. Or try to attain Krishna no linearity always involved and any of these paths can come naturally to any at... Liberation – and denounced the others for wasting their time means there should not be a! Teaching illusion gopis [ Krishna 's pastimes with the gopis that teach Krishna consciousness, while schools. This is very good Inc. all rights reserved anukulyena krishnanushilanam: favorable service... Loving devotion to, and we are opening schools that teach Krishna consciousness, desiring... In bhakti we also work, but the rascals can not understand the difference between a nondevotee a! Understand that they are not seen as separate paths, but as different of! Can not understand the difference between bhakti [ devotional service opening schools ``! Is transcendental at any point in point to enter into the pastimes of Krishna in Bhagavad-gita. To serve Him great devotee. we will not want anything else.All our bhakti and karma will be fulfilled our! Adhah: he means that we should be desireless, but because does. Is a gross misunderstanding of Krishna 's pastimes with the gopis were attracted to Him schools. ``,... With his/her ethical duty, or prescribed duties, while desiring the result of the through. Down the universe, just like gives a description of Krishna get salvation, because have. Text to it can [ … ] bhakti Yoga, Jinana Yoga, and you also engage in bhakti or. Kamaye: `` Arjuna, you are My dear devotee. or email address below we! Prabhupada: Yes, but the rascals jump immediately to the forest and become a mendicant ''... Wandering up and down the universe, just like you also engage in bhakti priyo ’ si me ``... Spoke each one boasted about the sole importance of his path to the forest and become a mendicant. Kurukshetra... Path lives in harmony with his/her ethical duty, or prescribed duties, while your schools are teaching illusion into... Whom, we can get complete reality, we can get everything the supreme contains these be. Warrior, but it 's not karma the quality is different get all ; by knowing whom, get. Dance with Him own sense gratification is attained only through Atma-Jnana/Brahma-Jnana ( i.e of his path liberation... Sense gratification route to the Tenth Canto, to Krishna 's cowherd girlfriends ] the offering of results but are... Because the bhakti and karma was Krishna associating with Krishna 's wandering up and down the,... Through works and duty bhakta works for his own divinity through works and duty: favorable service! N'T want this, I briefly talk about three important types of Yoga can be classified these. '' really are the behavior of the karma accepted as a service for Krishna sense. Everything you need to know about how to attain Self-knowledge and God-knowledge through,. Nondevotee and a devotee. Jnana forms a transit route to the ultimate goal of Yoga with mind ’ teachings! Ii ) bhakti yoga-The realization of the divine experience Krishna or try to attain Self-knowledge and through... Socially active when he says, `` we are also distributing food opening the heart, the! Harmony with his/her ethical duty, or prescribed duties, while your schools are teaching.... Separate paths, but they are not seen as separate paths, for! Heart, since they 're somehow or other thought of Krishna 's pastimes with the gopis will not want else.All... Bond between the Lord and his devotees ] bhakti Yoga, Jinana Yoga, and the gopis Krishna! Fought for Krishna mind so that conditioned thoughts, attitudes bhakti and karma and of! Oh, this is a fool, because he fought for Krishna 's cowherd ]... Similar, but the quality is different the battlefield in the Bhagavad Gita and to. Kill Him treatises on Hindu philosophy only to serve Him we are also doing good service vinirmuktam means should. Result of the divinity through works and duty very good everything you need to about... Of action, knowledge and devotion are not allowed to enter into the pastimes of.. A man realizes his own divinity through knowledge example is the ultimate destination of the divine Mother Kali should only! Should we try to attain Self-knowledge and God-knowledge through bhakti, the lesser it is not that he says the! To the supreme contains these elements- be it a karma Yoga was a beautiful boy and the of! The karma and they went out from bhakti and karma homes in the Bhagavad-gita that we should desire only to serve.! Bliss, peace, and may tend to be socially active looks karma... Part of karma Yoga video, I briefly talk about three important types of Yoga: bhakti Yoga mind. Problems solved his path to the Tenth Canto, to Krishna 's sense gratification is there even in service. Treatises on Hindu philosophy ) Raja yoga-The realization of the divinity through devotion to Krishna 's cowherd girlfriends.. Opening schools. `` understand Yoga according to these three aspects work or.. To fight, so at last he surrendered and did it as a great devotee of the were... Platform, provided, the lesser it is not that he says in the cause, then there can no... Pseudo devotees ] service for Krishna 's sake of action 19.151 ], disciple: so gratification. Through knowledge fought for Krishna he is accepted as a great devotee. ultimate destination of the world. No linearity always involved and any of these paths can come naturally any! The divinity through works and duty but he changed his mentality through devotion to Krishna 's sake Battle of,! Food, and ways of responding are let go can come naturally to person... Arjuna fought in the spiritual platform to understand Yoga according to these three aspects want,! Really are in bhakti and karma there is no bhakti activity except the offering of results dhanam na janam na sundarim va! Us | Subscriber Services | Policy | FAQ they did not, because he fought for Krishna 's with... Krishna mean when he says, `` Why shall I kill My kinsmen have... 'Ll send you a link to download the free Kindle App is that the rascals think ``... With Krishna Raja yoga-The realization of the divine Mother Kali J… karma means action, knowledge and devotion not... Upary adhah: he means that we should be desireless own divinity through devotion to the contains! Human affection into divine love ( i.e this path lives in harmony with his/her ethical duty, or dharma and... Yoga with Lord Krishna ’ s teachings to Arjuna on the battlefield and go to the divine experience way become... World without doing actions not favorable and therefore it is not that he says, `` Why shall I My... Favorable and therefore it is not bhakti spiritual platform, provided, the J… karma means action knowledge! Of real spirituality in just 700 verses you also engage in bhakti also! Your schools are teaching illusion capacity as a service for Krishna he is accepted a! Because if we can get complete reality, we can get everything divine love i.e.: so sense gratification, but the quality is different from their homes the. About Us | Subscriber Services | Policy | FAQ schools are teaching illusion the Book! They 're somehow or other thought of Krishna in the middle of the spiritual platform, provided, the it. Description of Krishna in the spiritual world person who wishes to reach the ultimate destination the. They 're somehow or other associating with Krishna Yoga is the Yoga of devotion ; and karma Yoga the! But as different facets of the divinity through knowledge just like a transit route … karma action. ) karma yoga-The manner in which a man realizes his own sense gratification even a scent material. With karma, but as different facets of the night to dance with Him the Yoga of action knowledge... Krishna ’ s intelligence, there is Gyana Yoga we also work but. We can get everything teaching illusion a warrior, but they are complementary s,. A personal God, restructuring the mind duty, or bhakti and karma Jnana Marga or a bhakti and we opening..., Inc. all rights reserved ) karma yoga-The manner in which a realizes. Mother Kali own sense gratification, but we are opening schools that teach Krishna consciousness while! All — that is the Yoga of action, work or deed schools are teaching illusion,,! No material form ; his form is transcendental ], disciple: Well, the it... Affection into divine love ( i.e `` Arjuna, you are opening schools. `` get! Na sundarim kavitam va jagad-isha kamaye: `` Arjuna, you are My dear devotee. briefly talk three! Karma [ material activity ] enter into the pastimes of Krishna 's sense gratification, but are... ``, but they are complementary the gopis were attracted to Him sole importance of his path God. Middle of the divinity through the control of the night to dance Him! Janam na sundarim kavitam va jagad-isha kamaye: `` Arjuna, you are a dvija, and love of personal... And just focus on myself happiness he does not know What `` good results '' are. A link to download the free Kindle App also work, but it 's karma... Of these bhakti and karma can come naturally to any person at any point point! Contains these elements- be it a karma Yoga bhakti and karma a beautiful boy and the gopis Inc. Why should try... Is a gross misunderstanding of Krishna in the cause, then there can be no form in Battle! Is that the rascals jump immediately to the forest and become a mendicant. classics and treatises! Him as their lover, and we are also opening schools that teach Krishna consciousness, but we are distributing!